Maximizing a home down payment can make sense: The bigger the down payment, the lower the monthly mortgage bill and the better the chance of building equity more quickly. But putting too much down could leave you without enough cash for home maintenance — or anything else.

Pinpointing the right amount involves balancing the advantages of boosting the down payment against the need to hold back money for urgent upgrades, life’s emergencies, and having some fun with your new home. There’s really no one-size-fits-all solution. 

Effect of a higher down payment

Calculating how different down payments would affect a monthly mortgage payment is eye-opening. Some lenders require only 3% down for conventional home loans, which makes getting in the door easier but means assuming more debt than with higher down payments.

Many borrowers ask if they should scrape together a little more, such as 5% versus 3%, says Rick Bechtel, head of U.S. residential lending at TD Bank. But that probably wouldn’t make enough difference in the monthly mortgage payment to justify doing so if it left you strapped, he says. 

But a higher down payment can make a significant difference if it means lowering or avoiding mortgage insurance. The insurance, which can involve upfront and monthly fees, protects the lender if the borrower defaults. Depending on the type of loan, making a higher down payment may eliminate some of that expense, if not all of it.

Kristin Phillips, author of The Debt Shrink blog, says she and her husband, Brandon, couldn’t put down the traditional 20%, but they wanted to put down more than the minimum when they bought a home in 2013. “Ten percent was a good compromise,” she says. That kept the monthly mortgage under 25% of their income so they could live comfortably. Eventually they built enough equity to eliminate private mortgage insurance.

Borrow with care

When deciding on down payment size, consider its effect on other aspects of your financial plan.

Twenty-nine percent of homeowners ages 21 to 34 borrowed from retirement accounts to help fund down payments, according to the Bank of the West’s 2018 Millennial Study. But the decision to do so shouldn’t be taken lightly. Borrowing from a 401(k) is particularly risky. After a job loss, the loan must be repaid by the next tax filing deadline or it’s taxed as ordinary income, with a 10% penalty if the withdrawal is taken before age 59½.

Using a Roth IRA to boost a down payment is a better option, says Aaron Clarke, a certified financial planner at Halpern Financial. There are no taxes or penalties on withdrawals of contributions. First-time home buyers who have contributed to a Roth for at least five years can withdraw up to $10,000 of earnings on the contributions, tax- and penalty-free.

Expect the unexpected

Thirty-four percent of recent first-time buyers say they no longer felt financially secure after buying their current home, according to NerdWallet’s 2019 Home Buyer Report. To maintain security, resist draining your savings for the down payment and closing costs. Leave some for an emergency fund, reserved for ‘oh shoot’ moments.

And homeownership includes plenty of those. To minimize surprises, review the home inspector’s report for items that need to be addressed, negotiate repairs with the seller if possible, and make a savings plan for remaining items. Budget for immediate upgrades, such as fencing the yard for your dog. Consider purchasing a home warranty to cover unexpected repairs or replacement of home appliances. 

Room for fun?

You get to decide how much you’re willing to trim expenses to get into a home. Achieving a dream can be incredibly fulfilling but it’s no fun to live in empty rooms, or a new neighborhood with shops and restaurants you can’t explore. There’s no wrong answer here as long as it’s an intentional choice. So, first, create budgets for your current and future housing expenses. Then consider the difference and how that will impact your lifestyle. This is easier than it sounds. You’re welcome to download our printable Homebuyer Handbook and use the template on page 5. 

If you’re still looking for that dream home, let’s chat! Contact me to schedule a complimentary consultation about your goals and how we can get you there.